Which brings me to rant number two of this vitriol-fueled post. What did we do to deserve being repeatedly subjected to the constant mediocrity of Neifi? The day Dusty is gone will be doubly-satisfying for me in that I'll never have to see that pudgy bastard in Cubbie pinstripes again. And if he's still starting with the new manager, then we failed to bring in a competent replacement. At best, Neifi should only be used as a backup every now and then to spell your middle infielders. Instead under the Baker regime, he starts at 2B and bats second. SECOND!!! Logic would have it that you'd want someone with a good OBP in the 2-hole. Apparently to Dusty, Neifi's .260 OBP will suffice. Christ, I wouldn't want someone with a .260 AVG in the 2-hole. But with only 4 BB's this season, Neifi fits Dusty's profile of a model hitter, since he doesn't "clog the bases" with a bunch of walks. Why would Derrek Lee want someone on 1B, when he hits for extra bases? That's just stupid.
And the next person to say that Neifi plays not because of his hitting but because of his defense gets punched in the throat. While one would assume that if a middle infielder with terrible hitting is actually starting for a team he must have good defensive skills, that simply is not the case. Last week when Walker had those two errors, people wanted his head on a stick, and for good reason. But some people actually said that we'd be better off with Neifi than Walker on defense. Really? For those that feel the need to make such an ignorant statement, take a look at this. I rest my case. So is Walker the better option? Yes, but only because of his mildly better offense. The fact is, that both are below-par 2B and neither are worth a starting gig.
What's that you want more proof of Neifi's crappiness? Fine. Lets list all 2B who have started 25 or more games that have a better fielding percentage than Neifi.
- Ty Wiggington
- Mark Grudzielanek
- Jamey Carroll
- Mark Ellis
- Jeff Kent
- Kazuo Matsui
- Mark DeRosa
- Marco Scutaro
- Craig Biggio
- Mark Loretta
- Brian Roberts
- Marcus Giles
- Tadahito Iguchi
- Jose Vidro
- Ray Durham
- Aaron Hill
- Hector Luna
- Placido Polanco
- Luis Castillo
- Orlando Hudson
- Josh Barfield
- Jose Lopez
- Jose Valentin
- Ronnie Belliard
- Brandon Phillips
- Robinson Cano
- Dan Uggla
- Adam Kennedy
- Ian Kinsler
- Chase Utley
- Jorge Cantu
- Aaron Miles
- Todd Walker
- Jose Castillo
- Neifi Perez
Now if you're gonna be one of those statistical buttholes that will throw out the "You can't look at FPCT, you have to look at range factor" argument. Very well. Here's the same type of list but looking at range factor.
- Jose Valentin
- Jamey Carroll
- Jeff Kent
- Ian Kinsler
- Mark DeRosa
- Aaron Miles
- Placido Polanco
- Mark Grudzielanek
- Orlando Hudson
- Dan Uggla
- Chase Utley
- Mark Ellis
- Robinson Cano
- Jose Castillo
- Kazuo Matsui
- Ty Wigginton
- Craig Biggio
- Ronnie Belliard
- Ray Durham
- Rickie Weeks
- Neifi Perez
3 comments:
I find it expremely disheartening that Ty Wiggington has more range than ANYBODY, much less Neifi.
I like Kent, but 3rd in range?
I call bullshit.
I was at every game of the series....It's not looking good TMS. Plus I didn't even get to see Murton get any minutes.
Post a Comment